“What’s the opposite of potatoes?”/“Potafingers.”

There are potatoes, but not potafingers. “Toes” and “fingers”—get the joke?
 
“RT @NMcShake: Potatoes or potafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by Lama on November 13, 2009. “potatoes?  please.  i eat potafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by Andrew Dyer on June 19, 2011. “The opposite of potatoes is potafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by Kate Mould on February 16, 2012. “The opposite of tomatoes and potatoes is tomafingers and potafingers respectively” was posted on X/Twitter by David Kagina on April 5, 2020.
 
“Potatoes imply the existence of potafingers” was posted on Facebook by David Marcus Title on October 2, 2019. “potatoes and tomatoes imply the existence of potafingers and tomafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by bry on March 30, 2020. “potatoes implies the existence of potafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by ✨Evayo✨ on July 18, 2020. “Potatoes imply the existence of potafingers” was posted on X/Twitter by Sable, Sapphic Wet Nightmare 🏳️‍⚧️ on April 30, 2024.
 
“Tomatoes imply the existence of tomafingers” is a similar joke.
 
 
X/Twitter
Lama.
@LUMMOO
and thats suppose 2b funny because…??! RT @NMcShake: Potatoes or potafingers.
10:55 AM · Nov 13, 2009
   
X/Twitter
Andrew Dyer
@lightbulb1221
potatoes?  please.  i eat potafingers
9:30 PM · Jun 19, 2011
   
X/Twitter
Kate Mould
@Katiekate119
The opposite of potatoes is potafingers. #Freud
12:00 PM · Feb 16, 2012
   
X/Twitter
Deborah Chew
@chewacheese
Tomatoes. Tomafingers. Potatoes Potafingers.
12:07 PM · Jul 22, 2012
   
X/Twitter
Alex Katz
@alexkatz95
What’s the opposite of potatoes? potafingers.
8:07 PM · Dec 13, 2012
       
X/Twitter
moved
@fratkidhaz
what is the opposite of potatoes??
potafingers
ba dum tss
11:05 AM · Aug 21, 2013
 
Facebook
David Marcus Title
October 2, 2019 at 3:24 AM ·
Potatoes imply the existence of potafingers
 
X/Twitter
bry
@bryony_youngX
potatoes and tomatoes imply the existence of potafingers and tomafingers
6:05 PM · Mar 30, 2020
     
X/Twitter
David Kagina
@kagnakagina
The opposite of tomatoes and potatoes is tomafingers and potafingers respectively.
#kagnawisdom
4:48 AM · Apr 5, 2020
 
X/Twitter
✨Evayo✨
@MurmurLilies
potatoes implies the existence of potafingers
10:32 PM · Jul 18, 2020
   
X/Twitter
Macko
@Mack_oj
Potatoes implies the existence of potafingers.
8:42 PM · Dec 26, 2020
   
X/Twitter
myelin.tmp
@myelin_music
follow up: potatoes implies the existence of potafingers
10:49 AM · Dec 31, 2020
 
X/Twitter
scone temple pilots
@js_thrill
The existence of potatoes implies the existence of potafingers
1:16 PM · Jan 9, 2021
   
X/Twitter
d ☻
@wystim_
mashed potatoes implies the existence of mashed potafingers
5:19 PM · Nov 25, 2021
   
Reddit—Impliedexistence 
CR1MS4NE—May 16, 2022
Potatoes implies the existence of potafingers and possibly potaphalanges
 
X/Twitter
jess!
@jessicobra
potatoes imply the existence of potafingers
11:32 PM · Oct 19, 2022
 
X/Twitter
Sable, Sapphic Wet Nightmare 🏳️‍⚧️
@GhostlySable
Potatoes imply the existence of potafingers.
12:06 PM · Apr 30, 2024