“Whatever sprinkles your donut”

“Whatever sprinkles your donut(s)” means “whatever makes you happy” or “whatever’s your choice/desire” or “whatever’s your flavor” or “whatever turns you on” or “whatever floats your boat.” The silly saying is cited in print from at least 2012 and has been printed on many images.
 
Similar food-related phrases include “Whatever melts your butter” (since 1975), “Whatever butters your biscuit” (since 1996), “Whatever bakes your cake” (since 1997) and “Whatever tickles your pickle” (since 1998).
 
 
Twitter
Nisha Jackson‏
@QuietBaby15
whatever sprinkles your cupcake!! 😊
5:00 PM - 15 Aug 2010
 
Twitter
k‏
@amayyaaa
Replying to @Hennepee
@sexyDIONboo okay, whatever sprinkles your cookies
10:39 PM - 31 Aug 2010
 
Twitter
Kerwin Delaney Jr.‏
@kdee_israluren
Replying to @PurpleFlowerrs
@Coolkidkai lol ok whatever sprinkles your ice cream haha
1:05 PM - 19 Dec 2010
 
Twitter
courtney brennan‏
@cm1nus
Whatever sprinkles your donut.
8:48 PM - 4 May 2012 from Seekonk, MA
   
Twitter     
Hafokuhh‏
@VeeLee_Hafokuhh
Replying to @_samanthaart
@__thugggin @_slotsimcc whatever Sprinkles Your Donut -.-
4:54 AM - 12 Jun 2012
 
Twitter
Gabriel Diaz‏
@G_Diaz22
... Or should I say, whatever sprinkles their donut
3:49 PM - 6 Jul 2012
   
Twitter
manlyman‏
@Squintees_
Whatever sprinkles your donuts b .
7:16 PM - 10 Dec 2012
 
Twitter
Sarah Belle‏
@sarahbelle93
whatever sprinkles your donut
11:35 AM - 20 Jun 2016
 
Facebook
Sandy Pony Donuts at Sandy Pony Donuts Annapolis.
August 30, 2016 ·
Whatever sprinkles your donuts!
 
Zin
Whatever Sprinkles Your Donuts
August 30, 2016
 
Facebook
ORA Miami
September 2, 2016 ·
Whatever sprinkles your donut.
 
Odyssey
Top 13 Quotes For The Struggling College Girl
At Purdue University
Dec 5, 2016
(...)
3. “Whatever sprinkles your donuts.”
For when the only thing you can say in response to someone’s actions is, “WHY?!”