“What do you call a fake potato?”/“An imitater.”

Potatoes are called “taters.” A potato riddle was posted on Twitter by Garth Loner on November 9, 2012:
 
Q: What do you call a fake potato?
A: An imitater!
 
This riddle—in the plural—was posted on Twitter by Hayley DeRoche on November 14, 2013:
 

Q: What do you call fake potatoes?
A: Imitaters.
   
       
Twitter 
Garth Loner
@DynamicBastard
What do you call a fake potato? An imitater!
9:49 AM - 9 Nov 2012
   
Twitter
unicornerd
@cikicho
What do you call a fake potato? An imitater!
11:26 PM - 12 Nov 2012
   
Twitter
low_kix
@low_kix
What do you call a fake potato? An imitater! HAHAHAHAHA (dies)
12:27 PM - 30 Nov 2012
 
Twitter   
Hayley DeRoche
@WeeHermione
What do you call fake potatoes?  IMITATERS.  ( flees )
3:20 PM - 14 Nov 2013
 
Reddit—3amjokes
Posted by u/CanYouSeeTheHorizon December 15, 2013
What do you call fake potatoes?
Imitaters
 
Twitter
Magmablood
@magmabloodmusic
What do you call fake potatoes? imi-TATERS #punsofpain
3:02 AM - 15 Dec 2013
 
Reddit—3amjokes
Posted by u/Bart_the_Cat February 14, 2014
What do you call a fake potato?
A faux-tato!
COMMENTS
FullClockworkOddessy
An imi-tater!
     
Facebook 
Happy Herbivore
August 28, 2015 ·
What do you call a fake potato? An ima tater!
LMBO!!!!!!!! (Thx Al!) TGIF Herbies
 
Reddit—Jokes
Posted by u/StaleTheBread August 24, 2017
What do you call a fake potato?
An imitater
 
Reddit—Dadjokes
Posted by u/thelummx June 9, 2019
What do you call fake potatoes?
Imitaters
 
LaffGaff
By laffgaff June 19, 2019
Fake Potatoes Joke
What do you call fake potatoes?
Imitaters.