“The crowd at the cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods”

“Finger foods” are small edibles that are eaten using fingers, but sometimes, as some jokes have it, “finger foods” are actually fingers. A joke was posted on the website Pun of the Day on October 6, 2011:
 
“The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods.”
   
     
Twitter
Terry Johnson
@Natural2Live
The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods.[Click to Vote!]
  - lol
3:14 AM - 6 Oct 2011
     
Twitter 
Alboum Translation Services
@AlboumSays
Pun of the Day: The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods.  #groaner
11:37 AM - 6 Oct 2011
 
Twitter
PUNS
@omgthatspunny
The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods. #punny
11:51 AM - 6 Dec 2011
   
Twitter
Gallop Creative
@GallopCreative
Pun of the day:
The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew excited when announced he would be serving finger foods. #GallopCreativePun
11:36 AM - 10 Mar 2016
 
Twitter
lorraine Jo King
@LahLahBean
The crowd at the Cannibal’s party grew silent when he announced he would be serving finger foods.”
#sidesplittingsunday
10:24 AM - 1 Jul 2018