“I’d like extra hot fudge.”/“Sorry, all of our fudge is the same temperature.”

” can you pick up a peanut buster parfait for me, with extra hot fudge?  (Sorry, all of our hot fudge is the same temperature…)” was posted on X/Twitter by Bill Jelen on August 2, 2013. “I’d like extra hot fudge on my sundae, please.”/“Sorry, sir.  All our hot fudge is the same temperature” was posted on X/Twitter by Bob Golen on December 26, 2021.
 
The “extra hot fudge” joke is that the customer wants “additional” (or “extra”) hot fudge, but the server thinks that the customer wants “extra hot” fudge.
 
 
X/Twitter
Bill Jelen
@MrExcel
@Excel_Diva
can you pick up a peanut buster parfait for me, with extra hot fudge?  (Sorry, all of our hot fudge is the same temperature…)
7:41 PM · Aug 2, 2013
   
All-Arts
VW Boys
AIRED: May 24, 2019 | 0:56:46
(...)
Went through a drive-through window the other day,
I told the boy, he said, “May I help you, sir.”
I said, “Yeah,” I said, “I want a hot fudge Sunday
“with extra hot fudge.”
He said, “I’m sorry, sir,
“all of our fudge is the same temperature.”
[audience laughing]
   
X/Twitter
Bob Golen
@BobGolen
“I’d like extra hot fudge on my sundae, please.”
“Sorry, sir.  All our hot fudge is the same temperature.”
9:04 PM · Dec 26, 2021
 
X/Twitter
Scott Abshire
@acredale50
I took my daughter to DQ last night,  ordered a hot fudge Sunday with extra hot fudge….the young girl working there said, I’m sorry sir all our fudge is the same temperature.  Good grief
10:33 AM · Jul 30, 2024
 
Facebook
Brad Barnes
March 26 gat4:06  PM ·
I recently went to McDonald’s and ordered a hot fudge sundae. I asked for extra hot fudge and the worker said “I’m sorry all the hot fudge is the same temperature.
To quote Gilda Radner I said “never mind”
 
X/Twitter
Bob Golen
@BobGolen
“I’d like extra hot fudge on my sundae, please.”
“Sorry, sir. All our hot fudge is the same temperature.”
8:01 AM · Apr 8, 2025