“Which Thanksgiving beverage is sad?”/“Apple sigh-der.”

A Thanksgiving riddle about apple cider is:
 
Q: Which Thanksgiving beverage is sad?
A: Apple sigh-der.
 
The riddle has been cited in print since at least 2006.
 
       
Brownielocks—Thanksgiving Jokes and Riddles, etc. (November 17, 2006)
47. Which Thanksgiving beverage is sad?
Apple SIGH-der
 
Just Riddles and More (November 15, 2009)
THANKSGIVING RIDDLES
22. Which Thanksgiving beverage is sad?
Apple Sigh - der.
 
Twitter
Vee
‏@VeeRemarks
#random i Got a joke for you..aLright. Which Thanksgiving beverage is always sad?@therealpinkyxxx
2:38 AM - 26 Nov 2009
 
Twitter
Hunger101 AZ
‏@Hunger101AZ
Seasonal Elucidation 11:  Which Thanksgiving beverage is sad? ........
Apple Sigh-der.
12:19 PM - 10 Nov 2011
 
Twitter
Bill Helton
‏@7colonel7
Which THANKSGIVING beverage is sad?  Apple sigh der!
11:50 PM - 15 Nov 2011
 
Parks & Recreation (City of Manassas Park)
DC KNOWS THANKSGIVING
Posted on November 28, 2011
(...)
Sarah said the saddest Thanksgiving beverage is apple SIGH-der.